Starfish Bay
2 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms · Sleeps 6 · 4.83 stars (6 reviews)
Welcome to Starfish Bay, your tropical island retreat on beautiful Duck Key. Surrounded by swaying palms, sparkling water views, and warm Florida Keys breezes, this charming villa offers the perfect setting for a relaxing getaway. Whether you’re sipping coffee on the patio, cooling off in your private dip pool, or exploring the nearby attractions of Marathon and the Florida Keys, you’ll quickly discover why guests love the laid-back lifestyle of Duck Key. The villa features two spacious bedrooms, each with its own en-suite bathroom, making it ideal for couples, friends, and small families. The open living area provides a comfortable space to gather after a day of adventure, while the fully equipped kitchen makes it easy to prepare meals and snacks throughout your stay. Step outside and enjoy one of the property’s most popular features—your private dip pool. Perfect for cooling off after a day in the sun, relaxing with a favorite beverage, or simply enjoying the peaceful tropical surroundings. Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, family vacation, or relaxing Florida Keys escape, Starfish Bay offers the perfect combination of privacy, comfort, tropical charm, and a convenient location for exploring everything the Keys have to offer. WHY GUESTS LOVE STARFISH BAY • Private Dip Pool
• Water Views
• Two En-Suite Bedrooms
• Multiple Outdoor Seating Areas
• Tropical Duck Key Setting
• Quiet Island Atmosphere
• Minutes from Marathon
• Ideal for Couples & Families
• Near Marina, Restaurants & Activities SLEEPS UP TO 6 GUESTS Bedroom 1 (Second Floor)
• King Bed
• En-Suite Bathroom
• Flat Screen TV Bedroom 2 (Second Floor)
• Two Twin Beds
• En-Suite Bathroom
• Flat Screen TV Living Room
• Queen Sleeper Sofa
• Flat Screen TV Kitchen
• Fully equipped with everything needed to prepare and serve meals AMENITIES • Private Dip Pool (7′ x 7′)
• Outdoor Seating
• Keurig Coffee Maker
• Drip Coffee Maker
• Blender
• Toaster
• Linens, Bath Towels & Pool Towels Provided
• Parking for Up to Two Vehicles NEARBY • Coco Plum Beach – 9 Miles
• Sombrero Beach – 12.7 Miles
• Bahia Honda State Park – 32.4 Miles
• Marathon – Approximately 15 Minutes
• Key West – Approximately 1 Hour IMPORTANT RESORT INFORMATION Starfish Bay is a privately owned villa located on Duck Key and is not part of the resort rental program. Resort amenities, including resort swimming pools, the saltwater lagoon, child care center, boat and trailer storage, and similar services are not available with this rental. Guests may enjoy nearby dining at Angler & Ale and Sixty-One Prime, book treatments at Calm Waters Spa, reserve fishing charters through Duck Key Marina, and rent boat slips and trailer parking from Duck Key Marina. IMPORTANT POLICIES FOR YOUR STAY Age Requirement. The booking guest must be at least 25 years of age and occupy the property for the duration of the reservation. This property is intended for vacation use only and is not available for worker housing. No Pets. Pets are not permitted per HOA regulations. Following booking, guests will receive a simple verification link confirming that no pets or animals will be brought to the property. No Smoking. Smoking is strictly prohibited anywhere within the property. Florida Keys Environment. The Florida Keys are a unique tropical environment where guests may encounter insects, wildlife, and other natural elements despite routine pest control efforts. Construction Notice. Occasional nearby construction, roadwork, or renovation activity may occur without notice and is beyond our control. Photo Disclaimer. Photos are representative of the property at the time they were taken. Furnishings, décor, bedding, appliances, and other features may change periodically as updates are made by the owner.
Availability
Location
This place was perfect! Very clean and up to date. The area is very quiet. You can go to Angler and Ale for a close bite to eat and drinks, but other places at Hawks Cay you have to be a guest of the resort. Some very nice affordable restaurants are within 10-20 minutes. We had no issues and enjoyed the peace and quiet.
Lovely place. Beds are great the showers are great. We enjoyed the patio and the iguanas that will come enjoy your morning coffee with you. We would for sure stay here again.
By and large we had a very nice time at Hawks Cay. The accommodations were nice. We did feel the need to wash the sheets before using the beds though. We were somewhat disappointed that the wooden dock along the canal behind our townhouse was closed due to the poor condition of the structure. We did however spend some time on other canal docks in the resort so all was not lost. All in all in was a nice time with family and the accommodations were nice.
We really enjoyed our stay. Very close to all great restaurants. We went to Key West twice and this was a great location to get there in about 90 minutes. We ate at the restaurants in Hawks Kay and really enjoyed the food and great service. Thanks for a very nice birthday trip!!!
Our family thoroughly enjoyed our stay in this lovely home! The house is bright and clean, with plenty of necessities provided. We enjoyed the backyard daily, including the splash pool. We enjoyed our morning walks around the premises and saw an assortment of wildlife. It was a great location and tremendously relaxing.
I was here with a girlfriend on an annual "girls" trip sans husbands and families! We have stayed in various Hawks Cay villas over the years and this was the loveliest of all. The unit was spotless, beautifully decorated, and very comfortable, and it appeared to have been recently painted. The management company was friendly and responsive both before and during our stay.